Mountain Dream Creamery in Pinetop-Lakeside

Very nice people. And the ice cream is fantastic. I had black walnut and pistachio. My boys had chocolate and a flavor called Superman. No complaints whatsoever the place is great.

Just completely worth it. Everyone is personal and friendly not a mean bone in here.Plus don’t get me started on the variety and flavors of the selection.Oh!! And the prices are very very very worth it.

We love Maureen and her amazing ice cream!! Only place I’ll eat ice cream!!

Service was great. Ice cream was ok. Better than a chain but room for improvement on the flavors.

We were just there at 3:30 approximately and the girl told us they would be open in a few minutes we waited but they never opened. There hours are 2-8 really terrible service you won’t be in business long.

The ice cream was delicious!!

Love their frozen yogurt!

It was amazing. GREAT GREAT GREAT ICE CREAM. The milkshakes here are made well, and additions to them can be easily added. My favorite part about this place is the owner, I have been here a number of time and she is always at the counter working hard. I respect her work ethic and love her combination of good ice cream, different flavors, ingredients, and a cold mixing board for things are mixed perfect.

This is my favorite dessert place, hands down! The ice cream is insanely creamy and flavorful. I would get it every day if I could. We recently ordered an ice cream cake with a brownie base, cake batter ice cream, and Oreo mix in. We also chose to have it iced with buttercream. Oh. My. Goodness! It was awesome!

So.. I just went to try and get ice cream at 7:00 pm at Mountain-Dream Creamery. The open sign was on and flashing but the door was locked. We double checked the hours, which stated the shop closed at 8:00 pm.. An employee came to the door and stated they were closed. I just wanted some ice cream...

Awesome ice cream. I always get coffee flavor. It's the very best. Sometimes with pecans added. It's been closed of late. I wish the owner and her family good health and well being. Con

Excellent. If you know the mountain it's hard to maintain a business specifically restaraunts. They do an excellent job of providing something that the mountain wouldn't otherwise have. Friendly service and amazing ice cream. Small town feel. Perfect business to be on the mountain.

Good place for home made ice cream in the White Mountains. Emphasis on the cream.

Beyond great ice cream.

Creamiest, freshest ice cream I've ever had. I wish they had one in the valley I would go all the time! Prices are very reasonable for the quality and service is very friendly and fast. 5 stars well deserved

I loved it!!! Me and my better half got a couple bowls of the best ice cream we ever had that day

Amazing ice cream and love that it's a family business. Great atmosphere and reasonable prices

Best ice cream around. It's been months since I went there and the owner remembered me from before. Best ice cream I've ever had. Get the Butter Pecan with the Cheesecake ice cream Best combo ever!

Great ice cream! Black walnut is fantastic!

Best ice cream on the mountain 💜💚🧡💛❤️

So fed up with the owners attitude. Always miserable, never smiles. Today she had an army of kids behind the counter playing with all the ice cream scoops and scrapers. The other kid screwed up my order and then the owner charged me an extra $2 after her employees mistake. By the time we were leaving the ice cream was melting. She is probably breaking some child labor laws. Don't waste your money...

Ice cream was okay. Was expecting something better. Nice little shop though.

Not as much quality as hoped for, not enough flavor, punch or pizzaz to justify the prices. Not an unpleasant experience, but not worth remembering.

Very bland flavored ice cream, not given any choice of ice cream for my order, very attentive then whole ordering told to hold on as "friends" walked through the door who apparently are more important than customers. Out of curiosity, do these "friends" bring you enough business to support your business that you can make the customer standing right in front of you wait so that you can catch up on the latest gossip with your "friend's"? And was over charged. Will not be back and recommended you find a different Ice cream parlor too. Employees choose to use some very colorful language that was very offensive, so we decided to leave.

Great ice cream

Excellent food .... prices ok.

Good selection of ice cream products and good service from two very nice young ladies.

This is easily the best ice cream in Pinetop. It's family-owned and operated, and they're very nice.

Definitely the place to go for the BEST ICE CREAM on the mountain. Freshest fruit, best service and friendly conversation. Make you feel like family when you're here.

Great customer service delicious ice cream and she even provided a candle and lighter for a quick happy birthday for my friend

Wish they had almond praline

Hands down best Ice Cream in town. Highly recommended!!

Banana split was small and somewhat ordanary. Service was as I would expect. The inside could be so cute, but it was stacked with boxes. The outside was in need of some cleaning. The multiple signs on and around the front door makes the door look dirty. With a little sprucing up and a little more personal attention this place could draw a big crowd.

This place is so delicious! They are willing to put together whatever you're craving into some of the best ice cream ever. If you're in the area make a stop!

Awesome little ice cream shop! Friendly service! Ice cream is yummy, not too rich.

It's a mom and pop shop we really enjoyed that cozy feeling it was our first time here but we really enjoyed it .

Delicious ice cream! We keep coming back when we are in town inventing new and more delicious treats with tons of different toppings the concoctions are endless!

Great place. Hidden gem

The worst ice cream I've ever had!! I ordered the caramel, which apparently was salted caramel, but not labeled as such. What the cone lacked in caramel, was more than made up for in salt. The boys running the place (I say boys because they were no more than 13), had no idea what to do while the woman (I'm assuming who was their mother) was too busy on the phone to help. I threw out pretty much the whole cone and we left in disgust. We will never return and I'd be surprised if anyone else who tries the caramel would either.

Really good ice cream! The banasplit and the cookie dough were amazing. The owner Maureen was really nice to us and gave us some advice on the area. We will definitely be back!

Best ice cream! Excellent friendly service!! We arrived minutes before closing, they served my husband and I, six others arrived after us and were all served. Thank You for your excellent customer service.

Nice service,nice family oriented!

Owner was nice, ice cream was the creamiest I have ever had...deliciousI love the owners sense of humor, photo provided was on the counter there 🙂

Maureen has the best ice cream. Especially the coffee ice cream with heath bar!!!

The best ice cream I have ever had in my entire life!

Good ice cream but quite expensive. The 2 times I've eaten here there's been quite a long wait as it seems they're always understaffed. I believe it's got potential if they had more help.

We called to ask a simple question and they would not pick up and when they did the acted like they’re phone was broken but then they put me on hold for over 10 minutes !!! That is disrespectful.

Best ice cream ever and very affordable . The young boys were extremely nice and good at there job.

Amazing! Recently ordered cake and it was awesome as well.